Doing a PhD and writing a thesis are not the same thing

By James Hayton,
May 23, 2016
I'm James, I'm a former physicist (PhD, Nottingham, 2007) and author of "PhD: An Uncommon Guide to Research, Writing & PhD Life".
Since 2010, I've been helping PhD students all over the world overcome barriers in their research and writing
My strategies have helped thousands of PhD students just like you to build confidence, write better and finish on time

A PhD is not, primarily, about writing; it is about research. The writing serves as a means of presentation.To me this seems obvious, but a lot of people assume that because the final submitted product is a piece of writing, that writing is the primary aim.So I meet students only a few months away from the deadline who have never even looked at their own data and have no experience or skill at all in analysing, presenting and discussing research results.They may have written hundreds of pages, and those pages may superficially look like thesis chapters, but they have nothing - absolutely nothing - in terms of research content.You might be a fantastic writer, but if your research sucks then you cannot write a good thesis. But if your research is good then the writing doesn't have to be fantastic; just good enough to explain what you did and what the results were.Do the research. Do the analysis. Discuss your results. Repeat. Then write.

Doing a PhD and writing a thesis are not the same thing

Recently, this site was included in a Guardian article listing top online resources for PhD students.

James Hayton PhD: A former nervous PhD student, now a post-doc, shares his wisdom about how to write a thesis without losing your mind.

Aside from the fact that I wouldn't describe myself as "nervous" and the fact I'm not a post-doc, I would not say that this site is about writing a thesis. It is about doing a PhD.Writing a thesis is part of doing a PhD, but it is not synonymous with doing a PhD. The thesis is the part that other people see, but it is only a tiny fraction of the work that should go into the research.

Yes, this applies to social sciences and humanities too

Let me make this very, very clear. This post is aimed at social scientists and humanities students too. The vast majority of students I have worked with have come from these areas, and BY FAR the most common problem is trying to write without having done the fundamental research work.Example: someone gathering interview data but who only spends (over the course of 5 years) about 3 days actually doing interviews. The quality of the thesis will depend on the quality of the data, and the quality of the data depends on your skill as an interviewer. If you have only done 3 days of actual research, there is no way you will have developed the skill required to do it well. The writing will be exceptionally difficult because, fundamentally, you don't have any good content to present.

See also:
Don't neglect your data
How I wrote a PhD thesis in three months
Writing your way to a PhD
Free Live Webinar:

How to adapt your PhD during the coronavirus crisis (and beyond)

Sunday 3rd May, 5pm UK time*
(6pm CET, 12 noon EDT, 9am PDT)
register free
*if you can't make the live event, you can still register and watch the recording

Stay up to date...

The PhD Academy:
Online training and support for PhD students

learn more...

For more detailed guidance and support...

The PhD Academy All-Access Pass

Weekly calls with James

You don't have to do it all alone! Get the All Access Pass for weekly group calls and Q&A sessions with James

Every online course

Build your skills and confidence with our detailed video courses. Go at your own pace and get advice and support when you need it

Get the book!
PhD: an uncommon guide to research, writing & PhD life

order now on amazon